The ambience of faith within which the believer engages in philosophy has seemed to some to entail that the believer cannot truly engage in philosophy at all.  This criticism is rooted in quite modern notions of how philosophy begins.  Unlike the assumptions … that the philosopher begins with truths everyone already knows – since Descartes the initial task of the philosopher has been taken to be the rinsing from his mind of all prior knowledge claims.  Various methods were devised to carry this out, such as methodic doubt, and the suggestion is that philosophizing is presuppositionless.  The philosopher ideally is uninfluenced by his upbringing and culture; he is an isolated mind, and little else, to which somehow questions occur.  (Ralph McInerny, Aquinas, p. 32)

McInerny’s point, that since Descartes “Philosophy” has come to mean something much different, is an idea that modern Christians need to keep in mind when traversing Aquinas’s thought for neat ideas on apologetics and evangelism.  Those who see Aquinas as forsaking God’s authority for autonomous reason are reading, anachronistically, a modern definition of Philosophy back into St. Thomas.  As I mentioned in the last post, Aristotle did not believe that he was reasoning autonomously.  Aquinas, in agreeing with certain of Aristotle’s first principles was not giving up his own but was recognizing that even the natural man can get some things right.  He was not doing Philosophy as we know it but “divine science.”

2 responses to “Why Some Consider Aquinas’s Use of Reason Autonomous”

  1. Jacob Aitken Avatar

    I am reading an essay right now, “The False Legacy of Suarez”, in which the author argues that protestants and modern day Catholics have read the idea of “revelation” wrongly. Your post reminded me of it.

    On another note, here is a fun little thomist book for you,

  2. Eric Parker Avatar

    Thanks for the info, Jacob. Hey, send me the details on that essay you’re reading. And give me an update on the wedding, etc.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: